Noah Erb and Abigail Heringer Have Been Going Strong Since the Very First Day of Filming Bachelor in Paradise. They Were Among the First Few Arrivals on the Beach, and Abigail Asked Noah out on the First One-on-One Date of the Season. Although There Was a Small Snag in Their Relationship That Almost Led to a Breakup, They Ended up Working Things out and Thriving in the Following Weeks of the Show.